Effect of Spraying Distance on the Scratch Wear Behavior of 8YSZ and Gd-Yb-Y Co-Doped ZrO2 TBCs

Abstract

This study investigates how torch standoff distance influences the microstructure, surface topography, and progressive-load scratch response of air plasma-sprayed 8YSZ and rare-earth co-doped GdYbYSZ thermal barrier coatings on an St-52 grade carbon steel substrate. Three nozzle-to-substrate spraying distances were examined: 80, 100, and 120 mm. X-ray diffraction revealed that the 8YSZ coatings possessed a predominantly tetragonal (t ') structure, with minor monoclinic fractions detected in the coatings obtained with the 80 mm and 100 mm distance parameters. The GdYbYSZ coatings, in contrast, exhibited a single-phase cubic defect-fluorite structure; their diffraction peaks appeared at lower 2 theta angles relative to undoped cubic ZrO2, consistent with lattice expansion caused by the substitution of Zr4+ by the larger Gd3+ and Yb3+ cations. Surface topography was quantified by non-contact laser profilometry, providing areal (Sa) and profile (Ra) roughness parameters for the as-sprayed condition as well as three-dimensional scratch-damage morphology after testing. Progressive-load scratch tests were performed using a Rockwell diamond indenter over a 2 mm track with the normal load ramped from 0.03 N to 30 N. Penetration depth, residual depth, tangential force, and acoustic emission were recorded continuously to identify critical damage transitions. Across all spraying distances, 8YSZ exhibited systematically shallower scratch grooves than GdYbYSZ; end-of-track maximum groove depths remained below 37 & micro;m for 8YSZ, whereas GdYbYSZ reached up to 72 & micro;m under identical loading conditions. The novelty of this study lies in combining torch standoff distance as a processing variable with multi-channel progressive-load scratch diagnostics, including in situ acoustic emission, depth profiling, and friction monitoring, to comparatively assess the scratch wear performance of 8YSZ and rare-earth co-doped zirconia TBCs for the first time.